![]() Best regards, Codename Lisa ( talk) 08:11, (UTC) Reply Please check the external links with the link checker tool for other redirected links - most will be ok, but some may lead to a wrong new location.The formal full license text can still be found at. License terms anymore, but to a customer-friendly summary information. Link Check - no DAB-links, no broken external links, however link 4 "Microsoft Software License Terms" does not link to the You see, the source is at the end of the paragraph, footnote. However, if you mean "subsequently Microsoft shares grew by 2.1 percent", it is sourced. I see that you said "the change in the MS stock" is not sourced. I personally think it could pass.- Jasper Deng (talk) 19:22, (UTC) Reply.Length: Short enough, with the right amount of detail.Media: All images have NFCC rationales, and are not bigger than needed.Consistent citations: Some things are not sourced like the change in the MS stock, but this might not be a blocker.Stable: Since when have we had an edit war on this article?.Well-researched: While the Softpedia references could be dropped, I don't see it as a blocker. ![]() Comprehensive: Very concise and detailed.Well written: Contains some vague/non-professional language, but probably not enough to be a blocker.Dank ( push to talk) 16:57, 16 June 2012 (UTC) Reply I don't know enough about Wikipedia's software articles to be able to support. Dropping my oppose, since the problems I pointed out and the problems mentioned below seem to be fixed.Best regards, Codename Lisa ( talk) 16:17, 16 June 2012 (UTC) Reply I contacted Dank on this talk page to revise his decision, now that his main concerns (i.e. Dank ( push to talk) 19:24, 2 June 2012 (UTC) Reply Prose isn't close to FAC standards, per comments here and below. ![]() Dank ( push to talk) 23:11, (UTC) Reply It's going to need some work on the prose could someone check it for obvious typos? For instance, just in the first paragraph: "computer virus, spyware, rootkits and trojan horses" (viruses), and "but not on Windows 8 that comes with built-in antivirus component of its own".Best regards, Codename Lisa ( talk) 19:01, (UTC) Reply Dank ( push to talk) 17:22, (UTC) Reply Per FAC instructions, it would probably be best to leave a message on their talk page, even though they're claiming they're not reading it. Even though FleetCommand says they're retired, they edited the article 10 days ago, and they've got the most edits. Best regards, Codename Lisa ( talk) 17:09, (UTC) Reply Although I am not the main contributor of this article, I see the article has received a peer review and I do not see any of the issues mentioned in the peer review, thus I am assuming that they are resolved. ![]() I believe this article on Microsoft Security Essentials has reached a level of quality that is expected of a Featured Article and may represent one of the best works of Wikipedia. Nominator(s): Codename Lisa ( talk) 17:09, (UTC) Reply
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |